Why does your fitness journey feel like an emotional rollercoaster?
Let's talk about something that doesn't get enough attention in the fitness world: the emotional journey you go through when you decide to make a significant change in your life. Whether you're starting a new workout routine, training for your first 5K, or completely transforming your relationship with exercise, you're about to embark on what I like to call the ultimate emotional rollercoaster.
Here's what I've noticed after years of coaching: everyone thinks they're the only one struggling with these ups and downs. But the truth is, there's actually a predictable pattern to how we feel during any major transformation, and understanding it can be your secret weapon for pushing through when things get tough.
The Science Behind Your Emotional Ups and Downs
Back in the 1970s, psychologists Don Kelley and Daryl Conner mapped out what they called the emotional cycle of change model. This wasn't just theoretical; they were studying real people going through real transformations in organizational change settings. What they discovered applies perfectly to your fitness journey, your new job, starting a new business, or any time you're learning a new skill.
The beauty of this change curve is that it normalizes the wide range of emotion you'll experience. It's not just you - this is how human beings are wired to respond to transformational change.
The Five Stages Every Fitness Journey Goes Through
Stage 1: Uninformed Optimism - The Honeymoon Phase
This is the most exciting stage when you first decide to get in better physical shape. You're buzzing with positive emotions, picturing your future self crushing workouts and feeling amazing. You see all the potential benefit and none of the downside.
You might spend hours researching the perfect program, buying new workout gear, or planning your meal prep strategy. This initial stage feels incredible, but here's the reality check - it doesn't last long. And that's completely normal.
Stage 2: Informed Pessimism - Reality Hits
After a few weeks, you start to understand what this transformation actually requires. Those 5 AM workouts feel brutal. Your muscles ache in ways you didn't expect. The benefits of the change seem distant while the costs of the change - time, energy, discomfort - become all too clear.
This shift to a negative emotional state catches most people off guard. You might start questioning if this whole fitness thing is really worth it. Your brain starts offering you very reasonable excuses to skip workouts.
Stage 3: Valley of Despair - The Make-or-Break Moment
This is the lowest point of the emotional cycle and where most people throw in the towel. Everything feels hard. Progress seems impossible. You're tired, sore, and wondering why you thought this was a good idea in the first place.
Think about a marathon runner "hitting the wall" - that moment when every step feels insurmountable and quitting seems like the quickest way to end the suffering. The pain of change is real, and your brain is desperately trying to get you back to your comfort zone.
But here's what I tell my clients: this turning point is actually a crucial role in your transformation. If you can persist through this valley, you're building the emotional resilience that will serve you for life.
Stage 4: Hopeful Realism - The Light at the End of the Tunnel
If you push through that valley, something beautiful happens. You start seeing real results from your efforts. Your new behaviors begin to feel more natural. You develop a realistic understanding of what this journey actually involves - challenges and all - but now you also have proof that you can handle them.
This next phase brings informed optimism based on actual experience, not just wishful thinking. The benefits of your actions become tangible, and you start believing in your likelihood of success.
Stage 5: Success and Fulfillment - Your New Normal
Welcome to the final stage of the emotional cycle of change. Your healthy habits have become part of your daily life. What once felt impossible now feels routine. You've not only achieved your goals but built the confidence to tackle your next change.
This completion doesn't just bring satisfaction - it fundamentally changes how you approach personal growth moving forward.
Why Most People Get Stuck (And How You Can Break Through)
The difference between people who succeed and those who quit isn't talent or willpower; it's understanding that these emotional stages of change are a required part of any meaningful transformation. When you know the valley of despair is coming, you can prepare for it instead of being blindsided.
Here's my advice for navigating each stage:
Embrace the honeymoon period but don't make all your decisions based on how motivated you feel right now.
Expect the reality check and have strategies ready for when motivation wanes.
Plan for the valley - this is where having a coach, workout buddy, or solid routine becomes crucial.
Celebrate small wins as you climb out of the valley.
Recognize your transformation when you reach the other side.
Building Your Emotional Intelligence for Lasting Change
Developing emotional intelligence around your fitness journey means recognizing these patterns in yourself and others. When you're working with team members on health challenges or supporting family through behavioral change, understanding this cycle helps you provide better support.
The process of change isn't linear, and that's okay! Your emotional responses will vary, and some days will feel harder than others. The key is knowing that these feelings are temporary stops on your journey, not permanent destinations.
Your Fitness Journey Is Universal
Whether you're starting kettlebell training, changing your eating habits, or training for your first race, you're following the same distinct stages that apply to learning any new skill. The first step is often the easiest - it's maintaining momentum through the different stages that separates those who succeed from those who give up.
I've seen this pattern play out countless times with clients. The ones who make lasting changes aren't the ones who never struggle - they're the ones who understand that struggle is part of the process. They develop strategies for managing their own emotions and pushing through when things get tough.
Remember, every new direction in life brings this cycle. Your fitness journey is preparing you not just for better health, but for more confident navigation of any transformational change you choose to pursue.
The path forward isn't about avoiding the emotional ups and downs; it's about moving through them with intention, support, and the knowledge that what you're experiencing is completely normal. Your future self is waiting on the other side of that valley, and every step you take, even the difficult ones, is bringing you closer to who you're becoming.
0 comments